Monday, April 11, 2011

Electronic Monument: Pages 33-57

Chapter Two: The Traffic Sphere 
(A MEmorial Prototype)


Prospectus
Ulmer opens this chapter by describing the MEmorial again as something that doesn't depend on acceptance to influence its audience, meaning that you don't necessarily have to agree with it to be impacted by it. I guess this is kind of like seeing a memorial on the side of the road for someone who killed themself while driving drunk. While you may not agree with their decisions, you are still impacted by the fact that this was someone's son/daughter and they were loved by someone. Ulmer then discusses the role of death in societies like ancient Egypt -- he brings up the monuments they built for their dead. Essentially, the challenge with the MEmorial is to create something appealing collectively and also appealing individually.


Regional Context
Ulmer discusses a tragedy in Gainesville that occurred around the same time as the first Gulf War. The two stories were compared side by side, the murderer being equal to Saddam Hussein, etc. Ulmer brings up the idea of the "mythistory" (myth+history) -- the murderer and Saddam shared qualities and both areas shared an instability brought on because of these people. The two stories also did another thing: they brought communities together (the national USA community and the Gainesville community). Ulmer compares this bringing-together to the 9/11 aftermath.


Problem Accident
This sections once again deals with the idea of "inventing the car means inventing the car crash". Ultimately, Ulmer states that to be electrate when creating the MEmorial, one must be able to reason at the speed of light.


History
Ulmer brings up an example of a soldier/philosopher during World War 1.


Principle Investigator
Ulmer discusses his ideas on pronouncing the word design with a Z or an S. He then states that in electracy, it could even be "de$igner". Each spelling and pronunciation has different meanings, and you must look at the one that you want to perceive as true "design".


Theory
Ulmer talks about Derrida and his ideas of chora. Ulmer proposes that another word should be added to a list of words associated with chora when dealing with electracy and the MEmorial: coroner. He talks about a wreck in Tennessee in which fifteen people died and fifty more were injured due to fog. He proposes that car wrecks are to sacrifice what shopping malls are to Christmas: secular support for a sacred practice. What I think he meant by this is the fact that the idea has been there for many years: the method of expressing it has changed though. There was sacrifice before cars and there will be sacrifice after humanity has moved on to the next mode of transportation after cars. Christmas was celebrated long before shopping malls, and has since evolved in the way it is celebrated.


Method
Ulmer brings up the idea of the rhizome here. He also states to "never disseminate any wild plant until we have firm evidence that it is unlikely to become weedy". I think the analogy here is that when thinking about the MEmorial, don't let any idea go until you're absolutely sure you don't want it any more. He also brings up a cool point -- that the American west's iconic tumbleweed tumbled in from Russia. That something seemingly so American is actually far from American.


Sacrifice
The idea of sacrifice is discussed here, and is talked about from the perspective of primitive civilizations. In early civilizations, sacrifice showed a continuity through the death of discontinuous beings. Basically, it showed a sort of immortality (more or less). Survivors saw that though some died, they were still alive.


Proposal
Ulmer here states that the 40,000 people that die each year in car crashes are necessary sacrifices. He says that they serve for a "value" which is ultimately greater than their individual lives (their loved ones probably wouldn't agree). He says what memorials are to ideals, MEmorials are to abjects (formless, nameless ideals). 


Visualization
The goal of the Traffic Sphere is to take car crash fatalities and make them perceivable -- to take them from personal loss and make it collective. 


Instrumentation
Ulmer here ultimately states that the reason NASCAR is so popular is because everyone engages in this in real life at the amateur level. Most everyone has been in (or has seen) a car wreck at some point.


Peripheral
Here, Ulmer discusses the idea of peripheral and the idea behind a memorial peripheral. He brings up the example of the Vietnam Memorial in DC. Here, the peripheral establishes connection between the acknowledged loss (the names written clearly on the wall) and the unacknowledged loss (the loss in the private sphere -- maybe men who came home with PTSD?). 


Abject Genre 
The MEmorial genre includes these elements (response of the Traffic Sphere is in parentheses)

      • Select an existing monument, memorial, celebration to which to attach the peripheral (Vietnam Memorial)
      • Select an organization, agency, or other administrative unit that has some responsibility for policy formation in relation to the disaster, to be the nominal recipient of the consultation (MADD)
      • Select a theory as the source of the rationale informing the consultation (Bataille 1988)
      • Place an (electronic) device at the site, designed to symbolically the establishes sacrifice with the unacknowledged sacrifice (computer printout listing traffic fatalities as they occur)
      • Represent the above features on a web site, including links to web representatives of the relevant sites and organizations and a simulation of the peripheral.
When juxtaposing the war victims and car crash victims, their losses are essentially being equalized. The soldiers died for freedom, the crash victims died for the abject value: the behavior that performs freedom. 

Cost-Benefit
Ulmer talks about the costs associated with cars. He says that the MEmorial does not object to nor glorify the social commitment to the car. The MEmorial only wants to make it recognizable as a specific kind of value.

Wreckwork
Here, Ulmer discusses the forces involved in a car crash, comparing them to "dreamwork" (i.e., compression, tension, etc.).

References
Ulmer uses a few examples that could go on the MEmorial for automobile accidents. I am not familiar with any of them.

Equipment
Ulmer talks here about satellites. He brings up the idea of the crumpled car after a wreck.

No comments:

Post a Comment