Wednesday, April 20, 2011

Electronic Monuments: Pages 115-145

Chapter Fünf: Formless Emblems (Testimonial)


Event
Ulmer starts this chapter off by saying that the issue at hand is the issue of the collective experience that emerges with electracy. The internet is represented as a living, thinking monument because of its dynamic, ever changing nature. Ulmer believes that academia is prejudiced against anamorphic thought. The MEmorial attempts to bridge this gap, supplying the electrate thinking of a tourist. The MEmorial does not accuse someone of being blind. An electrate student should not just argue a topic in a paper, but also designs a concetto in a MEmorial. The MEmorial does not operate in a vertical way but in a horizontal way -- connecting with the puns of a computer screen "screening" (like blocking a gaze). With the mystory, egents used the theory of the punctum and the popcycle to find the embelm and in that way, shed light on the issue. With the MEmorial, egents use outside disasters to shed light on their own inner conditions ("I am the event"). Why is the ME emphasized in MEmorial? For now, it justifies the unique relationship with ME and death. The EmerAgency helps a community to see the death's head (the 
vanitas) and tries to work out a way to solve disasters.




                         A vanitas painting


The process of the MEmorial is as such:


1)Begins with a sting from a news story.
2) Sting signals the activation of a border zone (What about the story is irritating? Why are you still thinking about it?)
The testimonials treat the event as an idea and as a mood and lead up to the proposal for the peripheral.




Gift(Concetto)
Concetto: a conceit. The EmerAgency must look at the inner workings of America and discover what is the source of shame. Ulmer brings up the sign and how it "means" only with its material element and its concept. He brings up the shapes on bathroom doors, and how they symbolize male and female. Ulmer brings up the Marlboro emblem from his earlier book. The most useful part of the emblem with this project is the translation of values across cultures. The MEmorial juxtaposes abject values with social ideas like the ad-emblem juxtaposes the movie star with the product. 




The Personal Sacred
Lacan's emblem is interesting because it shows a way to make something literate into electrate. The literate is expanded to include the chora. Continuing his bathroom example throughout the chapter, Ulmer states that the bathroom is a modern example of a sacred place. 




The Safety Patrol
Ulmer brings up an anecdote of having chaperoned a school trip for his son. He says that trips to places of historical importance have become a staple in American society. The children had little interest in the monuments, and experienced the trip in a "distracted" way. The "bar" here is represented by the safety patrol uniform the children wore, with their sash representing the separation of meaning in language. Ulmer states that the "MEmorial reveals to its makers the location of the border which passes through them".




Mourning
Ulmer talks about the Vietnam Memorial and how specific behaviors bought by the sacrifice are usually forgotten. That is the problem with the abject -- the multivalent status at one structure. Part of the consultancy here is to understand why some losses aren't recognized as a collective sacrifice.




Formless Value
"Formless gives access to the abandoned, neglected modern sacred found at this level of experience. In this same way that the electrate logic of conduction does without the abstraction of concepts, electrate ethics does without the transcendence of ideals." The general abjection is brought up here, and the sting is brought up here to make concepts leak together.




"Kindertotenlieder"
"children-dead-song
". The first step in making a MEmorial is to notice the loss in a community that does not accept it as a sacrifice. 






Sublime Abuse
The MEmorial attempts to bring abject losses to the attention of the public without making them ideals. The MEmorial often turns out to be tourist repulsion. Continuing his example of the murdered boy, Ulmer says that the community was disgusted by his murder but does not accept it as a sacrifice so that a way of life can continue.


Writing the Disaster

Here, we use the emblem to represent a disaster we cannot feel. Electrate writing is not clear and simple, but is obtuse and complex. 




Pulsation
Electracy makes it possible to revisit relationships with disaster. In writing it, you find the group subject within yourself. The goal of MEmorials is to find a collective self-knowledge. 




Jacobin States
The Jacobin idea for problem solving is that one should establish committees of public safety in one's area of interest. The EmerAgency combines the problem solving methods of Jacobin and instrumental engineering. The EmerAgent should find oneself in the feeling of a committee of public safety.

Monday, April 18, 2011

Electronic Monuments: Pages 83-112

Chapter Four: Transversal (Into Cyberspace)


Ulmer starts off by saying that news is a form of entertainment governed by the motive of profit. News has to sizzle to sell. The forms and practices of entertainment are designed to filter as much as convey information. News still has the power to sting (the punctum). The egent must meditate the formation of identity at the individual and the collective levels. 


Simulacrum
Simulacrum is "a slight, unreal, or superficial likeness or semblance". Ulmer brings up the idea of thinking with conduction, and says that egents must learn mapping and have to locate and engage with the hole that opens the whole. We are witnessing the equivalent for the group subject of Socrates questioning Euthyphro about impiety. 


A Machinic Assemblage
Ulmer brings up the idea of a trans-gendered individual and how their experience can appeal to the collective audience. 


Cyberspace Testimony
Ulmer states that the trans-gendered man's experience is like what happens to electrate people as they become image. Cyberspace is important to us because it represents the transformation into electracy. 


Emblematic Disasters
The move from literacy to electacy includes the invention of a category that is the image equivalent of the concept. The emblem here is like the Baroque invention. The impresa/emblem indicates how the egent testifies with respect to the disaster. The egent is the undertaker of the disaster (the "me" in MEmorial).


Transvaluation of Virtue
The MEmorial treats a disaster as a source for understanding values, rather than trying to impose a predetermined meaning on the disaster. The monad (the individual soul) expresses the entire world obscurely. The proper context for the invention of photography was the longing for a perfect universal language. The MEmorial continues the quest for universal peace and harmony.



Sunday, April 17, 2011

Electronic Monuments: Pages 57-82

Chapter Three: The Call (Abject Monuments)


Ulmer opens by saying this chapter will explore the MEmorial through art and popular culture. The MEmorial consists of two parts: the peripheral (proposal for an electronic device to be placed at the site of an existing monument associating it with an abject sacrifice) and a testimonial (web site representing a meditation on the abject sacrifice). The function of the MEmorial is to call attention to the abject (the unacknowledged).


Reasoneon
Image reasoning is the experience of a neon sign, evoking the mood of the urban setting and the atmosphere of the street.


The Auratic Axes
"What clarity is to literate truth, aura is to electrate truth." The assumption of the MEmorial is that the event was not directly witnesses by the egents, but was only experienced through image. Ulmer brings up the idea of compassion fatigue: that since we can experience all the sad events of the world, we begin to care less. The task of the MEmorial is to show how a consultation on a social issue cohere around the rhetorical sense of trauma. NEWS + ART = TESTIMONIAL. Ulmer states that there is a connection between disasters and books: disasters stimulate creativity, books affect us all like disasters (art never comes from happiness, right?)


Getting the News
The egent must learn to notice the effect of correspondence in which the environment event happens. 


Countermonuments
Ulmer states that the next step in the process if to consider an arts approach to monumentality; egents must write the disaster in the middle voice (neither active nor passive).


Revolutionary Monuments
Ulmer says that "Problems B Us" works only as a collective of the EmerAgency. The purpose is not to impose one virtue-vice, but to open a fifth estate of egent pupils.

Monday, April 11, 2011

Electronic Monument: Pages 33-57

Chapter Two: The Traffic Sphere 
(A MEmorial Prototype)


Prospectus
Ulmer opens this chapter by describing the MEmorial again as something that doesn't depend on acceptance to influence its audience, meaning that you don't necessarily have to agree with it to be impacted by it. I guess this is kind of like seeing a memorial on the side of the road for someone who killed themself while driving drunk. While you may not agree with their decisions, you are still impacted by the fact that this was someone's son/daughter and they were loved by someone. Ulmer then discusses the role of death in societies like ancient Egypt -- he brings up the monuments they built for their dead. Essentially, the challenge with the MEmorial is to create something appealing collectively and also appealing individually.


Regional Context
Ulmer discusses a tragedy in Gainesville that occurred around the same time as the first Gulf War. The two stories were compared side by side, the murderer being equal to Saddam Hussein, etc. Ulmer brings up the idea of the "mythistory" (myth+history) -- the murderer and Saddam shared qualities and both areas shared an instability brought on because of these people. The two stories also did another thing: they brought communities together (the national USA community and the Gainesville community). Ulmer compares this bringing-together to the 9/11 aftermath.


Problem Accident
This sections once again deals with the idea of "inventing the car means inventing the car crash". Ultimately, Ulmer states that to be electrate when creating the MEmorial, one must be able to reason at the speed of light.


History
Ulmer brings up an example of a soldier/philosopher during World War 1.


Principle Investigator
Ulmer discusses his ideas on pronouncing the word design with a Z or an S. He then states that in electracy, it could even be "de$igner". Each spelling and pronunciation has different meanings, and you must look at the one that you want to perceive as true "design".


Theory
Ulmer talks about Derrida and his ideas of chora. Ulmer proposes that another word should be added to a list of words associated with chora when dealing with electracy and the MEmorial: coroner. He talks about a wreck in Tennessee in which fifteen people died and fifty more were injured due to fog. He proposes that car wrecks are to sacrifice what shopping malls are to Christmas: secular support for a sacred practice. What I think he meant by this is the fact that the idea has been there for many years: the method of expressing it has changed though. There was sacrifice before cars and there will be sacrifice after humanity has moved on to the next mode of transportation after cars. Christmas was celebrated long before shopping malls, and has since evolved in the way it is celebrated.


Method
Ulmer brings up the idea of the rhizome here. He also states to "never disseminate any wild plant until we have firm evidence that it is unlikely to become weedy". I think the analogy here is that when thinking about the MEmorial, don't let any idea go until you're absolutely sure you don't want it any more. He also brings up a cool point -- that the American west's iconic tumbleweed tumbled in from Russia. That something seemingly so American is actually far from American.


Sacrifice
The idea of sacrifice is discussed here, and is talked about from the perspective of primitive civilizations. In early civilizations, sacrifice showed a continuity through the death of discontinuous beings. Basically, it showed a sort of immortality (more or less). Survivors saw that though some died, they were still alive.


Proposal
Ulmer here states that the 40,000 people that die each year in car crashes are necessary sacrifices. He says that they serve for a "value" which is ultimately greater than their individual lives (their loved ones probably wouldn't agree). He says what memorials are to ideals, MEmorials are to abjects (formless, nameless ideals). 


Visualization
The goal of the Traffic Sphere is to take car crash fatalities and make them perceivable -- to take them from personal loss and make it collective. 


Instrumentation
Ulmer here ultimately states that the reason NASCAR is so popular is because everyone engages in this in real life at the amateur level. Most everyone has been in (or has seen) a car wreck at some point.


Peripheral
Here, Ulmer discusses the idea of peripheral and the idea behind a memorial peripheral. He brings up the example of the Vietnam Memorial in DC. Here, the peripheral establishes connection between the acknowledged loss (the names written clearly on the wall) and the unacknowledged loss (the loss in the private sphere -- maybe men who came home with PTSD?). 


Abject Genre 
The MEmorial genre includes these elements (response of the Traffic Sphere is in parentheses)

      • Select an existing monument, memorial, celebration to which to attach the peripheral (Vietnam Memorial)
      • Select an organization, agency, or other administrative unit that has some responsibility for policy formation in relation to the disaster, to be the nominal recipient of the consultation (MADD)
      • Select a theory as the source of the rationale informing the consultation (Bataille 1988)
      • Place an (electronic) device at the site, designed to symbolically the establishes sacrifice with the unacknowledged sacrifice (computer printout listing traffic fatalities as they occur)
      • Represent the above features on a web site, including links to web representatives of the relevant sites and organizations and a simulation of the peripheral.
When juxtaposing the war victims and car crash victims, their losses are essentially being equalized. The soldiers died for freedom, the crash victims died for the abject value: the behavior that performs freedom. 

Cost-Benefit
Ulmer talks about the costs associated with cars. He says that the MEmorial does not object to nor glorify the social commitment to the car. The MEmorial only wants to make it recognizable as a specific kind of value.

Wreckwork
Here, Ulmer discusses the forces involved in a car crash, comparing them to "dreamwork" (i.e., compression, tension, etc.).

References
Ulmer uses a few examples that could go on the MEmorial for automobile accidents. I am not familiar with any of them.

Equipment
Ulmer talks here about satellites. He brings up the idea of the crumpled car after a wreck.

Electronic Monuments: Pages 1-33

Introduction: The EmerAgency


Ulmer introduces what (I think) will be the ultimate assignment of this book: the MEmorial. The idea of the internet's real time having replaced face-to-face time is brought up, along with the "replacers" of television, photography, cinema, etc. Is it possible to create a virtual city? The answer, of course, is yes, it is possible; it has been done. Virtual cities appear in movies (like the CGI storyline of Avatar) and video games (the Grand Theft Auto series is brought to mind, along with basically every other game ever) but do they replace actual IRL cities? No. And I don't think they will (at least, not for many years). Ulmer brings up the idea of "terminal identity"- the weakening of the borders of identity associated with a reduced mental map (the loss of the real city). Ulmer states that in electracy, the borders of identity (collective or individual) are writable. Virilio states that to reclaim the living city is to revitalize writing and language (agreed). The idea that "inventing a ship is inventing a shipwreck" stood out to me. 


Chapter One: Metamorphic Rocks (Founding Tourists)


Cognitive Jurisdiction
-"The Emeragency is to intervene in tourism at the level of practice, and to propose not more promotion of what already exists but to produce a new kind of tourist destination (destiny) and behavior, around which might form an electrate civic sphere."


Theoria
-Bring ups Solon (wise ancient Greek)-first theorist and first tourist; came up with "theoria".


Target Practice
MEmorialization is not tourism, but it is the analogy for how EmerAgency uses the internet to solve problems.


Florida Rushmore
Proposal includes:
1. State desires not only to promote tourism, but to improve it.
2. Monumental practices are magnets attracting tourists to specific sites.
3. Tourism and monuments form a rhizome that in practice constructs the political unconscious of a culture.
4. An important public policy issue after 1992 concerns the revision of American natural identity in the new postcolonial era of multiculturalism.
5.Theoria names a forgotten function for tourism in which the process of cultural invention though sightseeing becomes self-conscious, reflexive, and hence potentially intelligent.
6. Critical tourism allows citizens to participate directly in the continuing invention of "America" at a time when "America" is part of global symbolic capital.
7.Conclusion: the EmerAgency deconsulting practice may be tested by designing a new kind of monument, specifically created to support the transition of a literate nation into electracy.


A Holographic Monument
Ulmer brings the idea up of projecting visitors' faces on the side of a sinkhole in Florida, as a representation of Mt. Rushmore.


The PopCycle
Ulmer brings up the PopCycle (Career, Family, School, Community) once more and talks about how it applies to this new project.



Monday, March 28, 2011

Internet Invention: Pages 278-298

Chapter Ten: The Ideal of Value
(This chapter seems to be one of the harder to understand, so I'm going to start with Office and then go through the chapter)


Office
1. Ulmer states that this chapter deals with happiness, and the exercise within is to compose an emblem of happiness. This is easily done, as happiness is sought in many different ways by everyone.
2.This chapter also deals with the mood of your mystory, in that it is the map of our own personal situations. 
3. Ulmer points out his own upbringing in a Protestant Capitalist society. He says that since he was brought up in such a situation, he didn't criticize the practice or try to change it; he accepted it as the way of this world. Knowing this, it was easy for him to look at his mystory and see how these ideals shaped his views on the world and life.
4. Values are obtained through cultural osmosis, more or less. If one is surrounded by values from the time they are young, one will subconsciously pick up those values. Attunement: the way mood mediates between this worldview and your daily actions. Enthymeme: all the narratives and arguments include in their structure the places of your worldview. Ulmer states that to understand what it means to be the other in a worldview, one should go to a booster store selling items from a rival sports team.




Studio
Ulmer begins this chapter by assigning the exercise of making an emblem representing one's own idea of happiness. He talks about how ad companies target a person's mood and that we should try to imitate that in designing this emblem. He talks about wabi-sabi again and the saudade (the samba feeling) and how these are native states of mind to the Japanese and Brazilians. He says that Brazil used the Samba like Philip Morris used the Marlboro Man as a collective identity. Ulmer speaks of three lessons to be learned from the samba example:

      • The states of mind are not determined, necessary, not essences, but historical cultural defaults. (Meaning that the "states of mind" are inherited solely because of history.)
      • Bourgeois commodity culture (the spectacle) is dynamic, tapped directly into sign currency, and will continue to attempt to usurp the Sender's position to control the imagined community. (Meaning that consumer culture is energetic and quick and continually tries to take over the Sender's role.)
      • "Blues" is the default mood of the Black Atlantic, and that every part of the Americas has its own version of this mood and behavior.

Commodity Ritual
Ulmer tells the story of when his son asked for a sports car for graduation. He then reminisces about when he took a road trip against his mother's wishes. He compares the two and then contemplates when he lost his "sports car" -- his thrilling happiness of spontaneity and danger associated with Lee's car and his own road trip.

Remake: Remarkable Meetings 
Ulmer talks about a teacher named Gurdjieff, an embodiment of Ulmer's fantasy life as a sage and the view of wisdom as exotic. He discusses his attraction to this book and wonders if the exotic locations had an impact on him. 

On the Road
Ulmer describes seeing a man in California who he decided was the epitome of "cool". He talks about the sports car again, and that the idea of the sports car was not its allure; the allure was what the car promised. Ulmer said that his quest to Mexico was "part quest, part flight" -- Mexico had a negative image associated with it and still, Ulmer had the urge to go forth. 

The Ineffable
Ulmer discusses his views of different cars throughout his life.

Genealogy of Morals
Here, Ulmer discusses a philosopher's book that has had an impact on him. He talks about the practice of asking "What is..." which is an idea that he says Western culture takes for granted, seeing as to how it is the basis of Western philosophy. That habit is one of the West's default moods: reasoning, definition, critical thinking. Ulmer goes on to discuss The Genealogy of Morals.


The Alienated Sage
Ulmer contemplates how his view of himself has evolved over time: from wise old man to soldier. Ulmer refers to another philosopher who declared that the "Normal Man" knows who he is and is happy with it. He describes the sage as "cool", mostly because he couldn't recall ever meeting one in person. In this way, he could make the image up in his mind up what the sage looked like, was, and embodied. Ulmer goes on to talk about the fact that wisdom can be found anywhere and is not a matter of "having", but "being". 


The Writing on the Wall
Ulmer talks about his experience on his road trip many years ago and while trying to come up with a parable about why his son didn't need a sports car, Ulmer thought about meeting two brothers while in Mexico. They went on to meet Siqueiros, a mural artist who also made an assassination attempt on Trotsky.


The Ascetic Ideal
"The sage rejects experience as a value." The first sentence of this page struck me, because my entire life, I've dealt with the idea that no matter how great an idea is, if you're too young, you will not be taken seriously. It makes me think of Alexander of Macedonia, and how outstanding his life was from a very early age. Of course, life expectancy was far shorter so that may have had something to do with his being taken seriously. Ulmer goes on to talk about his time in graduate school while the Vietnam War was going on. Ulmer believed that the road to wisdom was through grad school, and if he could get that degree, he would then "exist". There is no direct access to wisdom or to experience, but there is always a gap between the two.


The Fugitive
Ulmer contemplates his time when he wanted to go to Haiti to go to a "desert" like Nietzsche talked about. He finds a hotel with the name "Montana", which he called his home away from home. He goes on to talk about the fact that Haiti has become so "other" with political strife and dangerous people that it is no longer considered to be of the "Caribbean". 


Predestination
Ulmer talks about his Presbyterian upbringing and how that repression led to his urge to be a "sage". He says although the Presbyterian church is no longer part of his lifestyle, the behavior has become a compulsion or a value. Essentially, the repressed upbringing put him in an ascetic cage, and his key to freedom was Mexico. For his son, it is the sports car.


The March of Humanity
Ulmer discusses what put him on his path to becoming a sage. What made it so appealing to him? He talks again about meeting the Mexican artist and then asks what the difference is between a revolution and a tourist attraction. Given time, the sites of revolutions usually become tourist attractions. 


The Wall
Ulmer states his connection to walls: "I hear my name, and hence my destiny (the wide image as a marker of predestination) in everything to do with walls and therefore with any murals that come my way." I think what he is saying here is that from the time he was born, walls have confined him in some form or another (the cage of Presbyterianism, etc) and to break down those walls, he went to Mexico and during that "breaking of the walls", his path to becoming a sage and achieving his destiny was laid out, so the walls actually helped him, rather than hindered him.


The Whirling Square
Ulmer discusses the Golden Ratio (1.618:1) and how it was the key to solving the mystery of the perfections of Greek art. It is the basis of the architecture of plants and animals. Ulmer concludes with the statement "To be wise is to have prepared in advance, like a celebrity's obituary, this diagram of destination." What he's saying here is that wisdom comes from knowing where you want to end up and doing what you can to prepare for it.