for the Twenty-First Century
- David Hilbert is quoted as saying that so long as something still presents society an issue or problem, it is essentially "alive".
- Robert Ray proposes that that logic can be applied to film studies
- In math, problems arise first. In film studies, theory arises first.
- Big question by Ulmer: "How do the new technologies of photography, film, video and computers transform what we call "thinking"?"
I. The Problem of Attribution, or Who's Responsible for This Shot?
- The major problem presented in this section is the idea of responsibility for art in film -- certain camera angles, still frames, etc.
- Ray brings up a shot from a film named Grand Hotel. He states that during the first part of the 20th century, many film goers would attribute it to the actress featured in the scene.
- Film making relies on many, many people from "specialists writing the scripts, doctoring the dialogue, running the camera, positioning the lights, dressing the actors, designing the sets, recording the sound..." and so on.
- Giving just one person credit for a movie is common ("Have you seen Chris Nolan's Inception?") but is incorrect.
II. The Problem of the Wind in the Trees
- The main issue in this section is the idea that the serendipitous occurance is lost in today's cinema. The example is given of wind blowing trees in a certain film. The effect of the natural phenomena gave character and personality and something extra to this movie's scene.
- It is pointed out that over the last half century, these events have been all but eliminated in film.
- An important quote by Vaughan: "The movies have always been a faith, and once we have lost it, we will never get it back." Essentially, what he is saying is that once we know how something works, the magic is gone. Once we know how CGI works, the magic of Avatar is gone (more or less). Once we know how Hitchcock used chocolate sauce for blood in the shower scene of Psycho, it's just not as frightening.
III. The Problem of the Blown Veil, or Contingency
- The section opens talking about a scene in a film in which a couple get married and as they walk out of the church, a gust of wind catches the bride's veil and her husband reaches out for it. The perfection of this "accident" was caught on film.
- "Talking about movies only in terms of directors resembles analyzing battles only in terms of generals."
IV. The Problem of Timbre
- This section deals with the issue of music in film and how music can add or detract from the movie it is used in.
- The reason music can add so much to a film is due to its timbre. Timbre is what differentiates music, be it the sound of a flute, a guitar, or even a human voice.
V. The Problem of the Uninvited Visitor
- This section dealt with the awkwardness of discussing certain film scenes and the facial expressions, moods, etc. contained within them. Critics have trouble when talking about these parts even today.
VI. The Problem of Benjamin's Ruffles
- The problem here involves working with the minutia of a film, to "squeeze the evidence" until it gives results.
- "What have Hollywood movies hidden from us? The work that went into them."
VII. The Problem of the Hallucinatory Spell
- The problem presented here is that when presenting a film discussion, the liveliness of the film is lost.
- "The goal of a twenty-first century film studies should be to penetrate the movies' veil while retaining their hallucinatory quality."
VIII. The Problem of the Three Audiences
- The three audiences (of the Civil War novel):
- "Professional Historians": People concerned with big-picture stuff. Reads and critiques the work of other professionals.
- "Buffs": People concerned about the military campaigns, weaponry, etc. Overwhelmingly male.
- "General Reader": Prefers narrative rather than solely historical novels.
- The readerships of Civil War novels are comparable to film study audiences.
3:The Florida School's Legacy,
or The Devil's Millhopper Joke Revisited
- Greg Ulmer created a public-broadcasting parody video involving poetry reading, in which he suggested that the sole meaning behind a poem was the author's life and upbringing.
- In doing so, he suggested that the meaning of Hamlet was a Floridian sinkhole. Readers then used literature to solve social and socioeconomic problems.
- Themes that are prevalent in the Florida School's work involve loss.
- Monumentality: part of the nation's identity; we still maintain a sense of national pride although the nation's founders are dead.
- Pets in the national identity: Pets teach us to mourn. The pets in shelters than are euthanized are martyrs, sacrifics for out national identity.
- "While you cannot take your legacy with you, others will read what is left behind as best they can from where they stand --mispronunciations, puns, misunderstandings, and all."
No comments:
Post a Comment